• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

DQYDJ

  • Blog
    • About Us
    • ———-
    • Investing
      • Personal Finance
    • Economics
    • Real Estate
    • Politics
    • Offbeat
      • Weekender
    • ———-
    • Disclosures
  • Research
    • Investment Research
    • Finance Research
    • Economics Research
    • Demographic Research
  • Interactive Tools
    • Economics Calculators
    • Investment Calculators
    • Personal Finance Calculators
    • Health Calculators
  • Show Search
Hide Search

The Lottery-Insurance Paradox

Economics     Updated: April 20, 2019 by PK Advertising Disclosures

Picture of a crashed plane hull.

Why would a rational person purchase insurance yet also play the lottery? It’s a great question – let’s discuss the lottery-insurance paradox.

Insurance and Lotteries are Opposites

This is a paradox that has puzzled economists for a long time. Think about it, a lottery is the exact opposite of insurance.

When it comes to insurance, a person purchases coverage to hedge against risks.  In a lottery, sums are spent for a long-shot chance at the ‘risk’ of a payoff. 

People are risk-seeking when it comes to playing the lottery yet risk-averse when it comes to purchasing insurance. What gives?

A Primer on Insurance

There are all sorts of types of insurance:

  • auto
  • home
  • life
  • health
  • death
  • even body-part insurance
  • and a universe of many more.

In exchange for a recurring or one-time fee, a policy’s holder hedges against some event occurring – say, in the case of body-part insurance, damage to a limb. If that event occurs, the policy’s issuer will pay out according to the details of the policy. This might be a lump sum in the case of life insurance, or the cost to repair damage to a vehicle in car insurance. 

In the insurer – insured relationship, the insured reduces risk by buying the policy while the insurer spreads risk by issuing many policies. The insurer attempts to collect total premiums or lump sum payments in excess of the cost of a negative event, and invest any money collected in the meantime.

To explain why a risk-seeking person might acquire insurance, it’s best to keep a few things in mind.

First, some forms of insurance come with a job, commonly health and life insurance. Other forms of insurance are required – for example, home insurance is required for a mortgage, and car insurance is required to operate a car in many states.

All of that doesn’t quite get to the heart of the issue – take car insurance, for example. 

Car insurance laws come with mandated policy minimums. In many cases, you can purchase cheap car insurance and set your coverage to the lowest allowable amount. In some states, you can even self-insure with sufficient reserves.

However, in many cases even people with risk-seeking personalities will get more insurance than mandated.

Winning the Lottery-Insurance Paradox

The Lottery-Insurance Paradox, illustrated by a 1995 Saab 900s
My Old Saab 900s… Only Had Cheap Insurance on It!

The lottery (and gambling in general) is the opposite. 

The ‘risk’ event is actually a benefit to the holder of a fractional claim on the prize.

In a lottery, a claim holder pays an agreed upon amount for a fractional share of a prize. The lottery itself generally has some defined payout which goes to a certain number of people at the end of the lottery. 

A gambler purchases a ticket or some other claim, and the lottery makes money by setting the total payout of the lottery to less than is collected in claims and administrative and advertising costs.

It’s a big business – in many cases governments will actually run lotteries.

An Economic Conundrum! Risk-Seeking Behavior

See the problem? 

Lottery playing and gambling is inherently risk seeking. The games guarantee that you pay something into the system, while placing risk on the holder of the lottery and transferring risk to you. 

On the other side of the coin, insurance guarantees you pay some amount for a policy but it will transfer your risk to the policy writer.

How can we rectify a rational actor both participating in a lottery and buying insurance?

Our friend (the Nobel Prize Winning) Daniel Kahneman and his colleague Amos Tversky developed Prospect Theory in part because of this conundrum. Recent studies point to a genetic connection with risk preferences, which even suggests that one gene can make folks tend towards more lottery playing (and less insurance buying) or the opposite.

If the lottery-insurance paradox is enough to get the Nobel committee to toss out Nobels, it’s enough for us to think about. Here are some questions for you to think about:

  • Why do gamblers buy insurance?
  • Do you think that people are, in general, over or under insured?
  • How do you think moral hazard affects the behavior of insurance purchasers, especially the risk-seeking variety?
  • How do you explain the lottery-insurance paradox?
  • Twitter Transparent PNG
  • Facebook Transparent PNG
  • LinkedIn Transparent PNG
  • Reddit Transparent PNG
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • linkedin

Economics gambling, insurance, Kahneman, lottey, rational choice, Tversky

About PK

PK founded DQYDJ in 2009 to educate and learn from others in finance and investing. By day he writes prose and code in Silicon Valley. He's mid-30s, married, with two kids.

[ Read more about PK ]

Primary Sidebar

Never Miss a Post

POPULAR  IN THE LAST WEEK

  • Income Percentile Calculator for the United States in 2019 Economics
  • Net Worth Percentile Calculator for the United States Economics
  • S&P 500 Return Calculator, with Dividend Reinvestment Investing
  • United States Net Worth Brackets, Percentiles, and Top One Percent Economics
  • 2019 Household Income Percentile Calculator for the United States Personal Finance
  • Net Worth by Age Calculator for the United States Economics
  • Height Percentile Calculator for Men and Women in the United States Health
  • Income Percentile by Age Calculator for the United States in 2019 Economics
  • Stock Total Return and Dividend Reinvestment Calculator (United States) Investing
  • Hours Calculator: See How Many Hours are Between Two Times
  • Who Are the One Percent in the United States by Income and Net Worth? Economics
  • Average, Median, Top 1%, and all United States Household Income Percentiles in 2019 Economics
  • Bond Pricing Calculator Based on Current Market Price and Yield Economics
  • How Many Millionaires Are There in America? Economics
  • S&P 500 Periodic Reinvestment Calculator (With Dividends) Investing

About DQYDJ         

We write posts and create calculators and visualizations to help you understand your finances and take control of your investments.

[ Read More About Us ]

Never miss another post:

© 2009-2019 DQYDJ.com

  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy & Disclosures
  • Recent Posts